In brief

  1. Four families of databases answer four different questions. Patents say who is inventing what, regulatory references say what is binding, scientific literature gives the upstream state of the art, curated databases explain how it all applies.
  2. Patent databases are free and the earliest signal. Espacenet exceeds 150 million documents, PATENTSCOPE holds 129.5 million, and publication generally occurs 18 months after filing or priority.
  3. The budget tipping point is the standard, not the database. Patents and official regulation cost nothing, standards and indexed literature are paid.

The question of which database to use for industrial technology watch rarely has a single answer, and that is the first trap. A design office tracking a competitor, a quality department following a change in standards and an R&D team looking for the state of the art do not need the same tools. This landscape organises databases by family, subject coverage and access model.

Headquarters of the European Patent Office in Munich

The landscape in one table

DatabaseFamilyWhat it providesAccessCoverage
Espacenet (EPO)PatentsMore than 150 million patent documents, CPC classification searchFreeWorldwide
PATENTSCOPE (WIPO)Patents129.5 million documents including 5.5 million PCT applications, cross-lingual searchFreeWorldwide
Google PatentsPatentsFull-text search and machine translation, with a simple and accessible interfaceFreeWorldwide
Data INPIPatents and companiesFrench industrial property titles and company dataFreeFrance
Questel OrbitPatentsPortfolio analysis, mapping and tooled alertsSubscriptionWorldwide
AFNOR, ISO, IECStandardsThe text of standards, and only that text is authoritativePaid per unitWorldwide
Légifrance, EUR-LexRegulationNational and European law in forceFreeFrance and EU
Scopus, Web of ScienceLiteratureIndexing and citation data for scientific outputSubscriptionWorldwide
IEEE XploreLiteraturePublications and standards in electronics, computing and energySubscriptionWorldwide, English
ScienceDirectLiteratureElsevier journals and books, engineering includedSubscriptionWorldwide, English
HAL, Google ScholarLiteraturePartial open access to the same outputFreeWorldwide
Techniques de l’IngénieurCurated documentationExpert-validated synthesis papers, in FrenchSubscriptionFrance, all fields

The table reads in three blocks. The first four rows offer public patent-search resources. The standards and literature block is what weighs on the budget. The last row adds curated syntheses to support practical use of knowledge.

Family 1: patents, the earliest source

A patent application is generally published 18 months after its filing or priority date. This provides a dated technical source for the watch. The interval between patent publication and commercialisation varies by project.

Espacenet, published by the European Patent Office, contains data on more than 150 million patent documents from around the world. Its strength is search by Cooperative Patent Classification, the CPC, which queries a technical field rather than a keyword. A keyword misses everything phrased differently, a CPC class usefully complements keyword searching.

PATENTSCOPE, published by the World Intellectual Property Organization, gives access to 129.5 million patent documents, including 5.5 million international applications filed under the PCT. Its distinctive feature is cross-lingual search, which automatically translates a query and searches collections in several languages. It is the tool that keeps an Asian filing from slipping past.

Google Patents and Data INPI round out the set, the first for its interface and machine translation, the second for French titles and the link to company data. Questel Orbit belongs to a different category, portfolio analysis and mapping, and is justified once patent watch becomes a function rather than a task.

Patent databases document inventions and their protection. Economic and technical sources complement this reading with industrial applications and projects.

Family 2: standards and regulatory references

This family answers a different question, that of what is binding. An industrial company monitoring its obligations is not looking for innovation, it is looking for the gap between what it does and what it should do.

Légifrance and EUR-Lex are free and are the only authoritative sources, one for national law, the other for European law. The distinction between a regulation and a directive is structural here, a European regulation applies directly whereas a directive must first be transposed.

AFNOR, ISO and IEC publish standards, and this is where the budget shifts. A standard is bought per unit, and only its text is authoritative. The question that comes up most often is whether a standard cited in a specification is actually binding. Check the current texts and the list of standards made mandatory on Légifrance. The subject is developed in our landscape of documentation sources for industrial regulatory compliance.

Family 3: scientific and technical literature

Scopus and Web of Science are indexing and citation databases. They help identify publications, citations and research teams. This is the upstream scouting tool, before a technology is even patentable.

IEEE Xplore and ScienceDirect provide the text, the first on electronics, computing and energy, the second across a very broad Elsevier perimeter. Full-text access depends on the publication’s access model and the institution’s licences.

HAL and Google Scholar partially open the same corpus. HAL, the French open archive, hosts deposits from public laboratories and gives access to author versions of otherwise paywalled work. Google Scholar offers very wide coverage of the scientific literature, useful for a first exploration.

Family 4: curated technical documentation

The three preceding families provide published inventions, normative requirements and research findings. Curated syntheses put them in context to support design and industrial application.

This is the role of curated documentation databases, of which Techniques de l’Ingénieur is a curated resource for the French-speaking field. The principle differs from the other three families, according to its publisher, the papers are validated and kept up to date by expert committees, in French, across fields ranging from materials to process engineering, construction and control systems. The question they address is not what has been discovered but how it applies.

This family complements the other three by putting their material in context. The appropriate original sources remain part of the watch setup.

How to combine these sources without spending all your time on it

The habit that costs the most in technology watch is accumulation. An organisation following fifteen feeds does not read them, it archives them. Three to five sources, one per family, handled seriously, produce more.

  • One patent source on automatic alert, on one or two CPC classes rather than keywords, and on the applicants being tracked.
  • One regulatory source, a Légifrance alert on the relevant headings, with standards monitoring added if the sector requires it.
  • One scientific source, an alert on a Scopus query or on the tables of contents of two journals in the field.
  • One synthesis source, consulted on demand rather than as a feed, when a subject surfaces and has to be understood quickly.
  • One fixed weekly slot, assigned by name. A watch with nobody designated to read it does not exist.

The general method, applicable across tools, is developed in our article on technology watch for engineers.